Image: MomJunction Design Team
Eyeliners complement your looks by adding definition to your eyes. The best drugstore liquid eyeliners are an apt buy for those looking for affordable cosmetics that can do the trick as they have a smooth texture and a no-compromise finish. These eyeliners are known to last longer, similar to any top-quality luxury eyeliner would. Well, if you are looking to experiment with some of these eyeliners, we have got you covered. Check out this list of top drugstore eyeliners that we have compiled based on the features, quality, and testers’ experiences. Pick a suitable one to give your eyes a classic look.
Top Picks
17 Best Drugstore Liquid Eyeliner
1. Best Waterproof:Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
Be free with the Stila liquid eyeliner that glides easily on the eye and provides a glossy finish. The smooth texture of the liner tip gives you an effortless feel, and its rich pigment stays on for long. This professional-grade waterproof eyeliner doesn’t smudge or get messy while applying. A single stroke is enough for a tapered look, while two strokes would make it darker. The eyeliner is available in different shades and colors to suit different occasions and tastes. Watch this video to get a detailed review of this eyeliner.
"I've been using this liner for a while and enjoy its smooth application and longevity. It's smudge-proof and waterproof, staying put even on hot, sweaty days. While removal can be a bit difficult, a good makeup remover usually does the trick."
2. Best Smudge-Free:Maybelline Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner
Maybelline precision eyeliner is a jet-black liner that intensifies the color of your eyes with long-lasting effects. You can stay smudge-free, chemical-free as well as untroubled with this liquid eyeliner. A sleek slide from the inner corner to the outer edge with the liner pen could add vibrancy to your eye shadow and make you look classy. Move your hand straight without a shake for a proper finish to go with any dress you wear. Check this reviewer’s video to learn more about this celebrity-favorite drugstore eyeliner.
"I've been using this liquid eyeliner for some time – it's smooth and pigmented. It does not smudge, so I did not have to reapply. However, the tip tends to wear out before the ink, which is a downside. But it still remains my favorite for daily use, and it comes off easily with makeup wipes."
3. Best Chemical-Free:NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
About 66,590 reviewers on Amazon have given their seal of approval to the product.
Apply eyeliner like a pro with this NYX liner, which gives a long-lasting, ultra-finish. Move the brush smoothly and get a straight or thick line as desired. This tapered brush tip drugstore liquid eyeliner lets you glide it effortlessly on the lids to give your eyes a defined look. The product is chemical-free, not tested on animals, and does not harm your eyes. Its rich pigment is smudge-free and waterproof and offers a shiny look. Check out this product review video to learn more about this drugstore eyeliner.
"My experience with this eyeliner has been good; it's smooth, glides well on my eyelids, and lasts a day. Nonetheless, it can be a bit stubborn to remove and lacks a fully matte look, but I personally find the slight shine appealing. It works great and continues to be my preferred choice."
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Best Waterproof | Maybelline Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner Best Smudge-Free | NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner Best Chemical-Free | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 4 x 5 x 6 inches | 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | - |
| Weight | 0.02 Ounces | 0.34 Ounces | - |
| Color | - | Black | Black |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 7,327 | 26,974 | 66,590 |
| Price | $24 | $6.38 | $7.97 |
4. Best Skid-Proof:L’Oréal Paris Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The 12,247 reviews on Amazon indicate that this product has a loyal following.
Glossy, stylish, and pitch-black, that is what the L’Oréal Paris liquid eyeliner is. The ultra-smooth texture of this super slim liner allows you to apply it with precision for a look that lasts up to 12 hours. It works effortlessly on the eyes and slides down to the other corners to give you a classy look. The smudge-proof drugstore liquid eyeliner can be combined with volume-building mascara to give your eyes a celebrity-inspired defined look.
"I have been using this eyeliner for years. It has a rich pigment, is smudge-proof, and has long-lasting wear. The fine tip is perfect for creating thin, precise lines and elaborate designs, however, it tends to dry out quicker if you apply it over eyeshadow. Great product overall!"
Point To Consider5. Best Dermatologist-Tested:Maybelline New York Ultra-Liner
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The tried-and-true product has earned over 8,114 good reviews on Amazon.
For a smooth and precise finish that lasts long, get the Maybelline ultra-liner that works comfortingly on the eyes and makes them super charming. It comes equipped with an ultra fine-tip brush and is waterproof, and its ultra-black pigment enhances the makeup look when used correctly. Use it tapered or thick with a single dip to augment the beauty of the eyes. This drugstore eyeliner is also dermatologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes.
"This waterproof liner is pretty resilient, rarely requiring touch-ups. It strategically combats watery eyes, particularly with its applicator, which makes drawing straight or full lines a breeze, even on oily eyelids."
6. Best Precision:Essence Cosmetics Superfine Eyeliner Pen
The Essence Cosmetics three-pack eyeliner pen is easy to use and suitable for everyday wear. It features a super-fine and felt tip-based flexible brush for bold, streak-free, and precise application and is perfect for achieving an everyday or dramatic cat-eye look. The highly-pigmented drugstore eyeliner is also cruelty-free, free of parabens, oil, and acetone, and gentle on sensitive skin.
"I adore this liner for its precise, bold lines that didn't run, even after a nap! It is also user-friendly. The pigment is rich, but it tends to dry out after regular use. Nonetheless, it's a good-quality product that's worth trying out."
Quick Tip7. Best Long-Lasting:Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner
The Covergirl Perfect Point Plus liquid eyeliner is an anti-smudge and 12-hour long-wear eyeliner. Its long-lasting formula is cruelty-free, waterproof, fragrance-free, highly pigmented, and gentle on sensitive skin. The precision drugstore liquid eyeliner features a super-fine and easy-to-control felt tip for perfect detailing without tugging on the skin. With a silky smooth matte finish, it comes in three versatile shades. Use this fade- and flake-resistant drugstore eyeliner to create bold eye looks with ease and enjoy the visible results.
"This eyeliner has a great applicator that glides effortlessly, and I love the pigmentation. It is great for daily use. I tried drawing sharp wings with it and even paired it with eyeshadows; it worked well for both. With a cruelty-free formula, this has been a cherished find!"
8. Best Non-Messy:e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner
Don’t hide your beautiful eyes; contour them with this makeup artist-approved e.l.f liquid liner. Its liquid formula is smudge-free, waterproof, and non-messy. One stroke of this liquid eyeliner on the eyes can bring that shiny, glossy charm to your day. The all-day liner comes with an ultra fine-tip brush that allows precision lining with a flawless finish and doesn’t pull your eyes. Simply move your hand from the inner to the outer corner of the eye for a defined application.
"This eyeliner has a smooth glide, which helps create precise wings. However, it has a slightly long drying time and can be a bit sticky and prone to smudging. Despite this minor issue, it does stay on well and can be easily removed."
Did You Know?9. Best For Sensitive Eyes:L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Precision Liquid Eyeliner
One of the best from the drugstore liquid eyeliner collection by L’Oréal, this waterproof eyeliner allows you to apply it with precision, like a pro. It is chemical-free and safe for sensitive eyes. Shake it, open it, and move the liner pen on your eyes gently. The jet-black pigment of this liner is enough to boost your overall look without any need for additional makeup. The expert-recommended eyeliner also dries quickly, making it a convenient product to use on the go.
"After trying various eyeliners, I found this product to be truly waterproof. While it does need a good scrub to remove, it withstands tears and sweating. The applicator lets me create both thick and thin lines. I wish there was more product in the container, though. Nevertheless, a reliable staple in my makeup routine."
10. Best Gentle:Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner
Neutrogena liquid eyeliner brings out the proper look of the eyes with its long-lasting formula. Formulated with natural ingredients such as coconut and honey, this eyeliner is gentle on the eyes and comfortable to carry all day. The waterproof drugstore liquid eyeliner is chemical-free and safe to use. Its rich pigment delivers visible results without smudging or leaking, and it doesn’t fray when you apply it.
"I found this hypoallergenic eyeliner very comfortable for my eyes. It applies smoothly, and the fine brush tip offers ample control. Although it can occasionally smudge on hot days, applying an eye shadow base prevents it."
11. Best Smudge-Proof: Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner
Milani’s Stay Put eyeliner boasts a smudge-proof formula and promises more than 17 hours of wear with just a single application. The water-resistant eyeliner delivers a matte finish that remains intact, even in sweaty or humid conditions. Available in shades of brown and black, the highly pigmented eyeliner features a quick-drying formula. On the other hand, it also stands out as an ultra fine-tip drugstore liquid eyeliner for easy and precise application with proven efficacy. The product is not tested on animals, making it an ideal choice for your conscience.
"I love how easy it is to apply this eyeliner, and it doesn't smudge or flake. However, I found the applicator to be a bit rigid; a longer brush would have provided more precision. Still, it's a worthwhile choice, thanks to its sweat-proof, quick-drying formula."
12. Best Quick-Drying: Jesse’s Girl Liquid Eyeliner
Jesse’s Girl is a subtle calligraphy-style liner brush for contouring the eyes with precision and creating a long-lasting effect. The ultra-glossy black liner has a waterproof base and is quick-drying and non-messy, thus helping you look fresh and classy all day long. Just glide this drugstore eyeliner on your eyes and make it as thick as you want it.
"From the first time I used this eyeliner, it became my go-to. It lets me create a sharp cat-eye look and stays put all day. The tip can feel dry initially, but a quick dip in some water will take care of it. Apply a couple of coats for full coverage. Also, it's easy to wash it off at the end of the day."
13. Best Long-Lasting: New York Color Liquid Eyeliner
NYC features this long-lasting drugstore liquid eyeliner, providing a strong black sheer finish. The tapered brush assists in getting the subtle finish and helps you wear it confidently. Its long-lasting formula is ophthalmologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It dries swiftly and is smudge-free, as well as fragrance-free. The creamy texture of the liner makes it glide on smoothly. Thanks to its rich pigment, you can wear the eyeliner throughout the day without any need for touch ups.
"I adore the matte black pigment and the smooth application of this eyeliner. The stiffness of the brush can be a bit hard to work with initially, but once you get the hang of it, it's worth it. The lasting ability is also quite impressive."
14. Best Waterproof: Ucanbe Liquid Eyeliner
This product brings sheer precision, great color value, and longevity in one package. The liquid eyeliner dries in a few seconds and keeps the shine for the whole day. The tip moves gently and enhances the appearance even without other makeup. This intense black drugstore liquid eyeliner is waterproof, chemical-free, and also works for lens wearers. It is ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-tested.
"I tried this eyeliner out of curiosity, and I really liked it. It's waterproof, vividly pigmented, and stays put until removed. However, the amount dispensed can be excessive at times, leading to uneven application. The brush tip is too thick for my taste. Despite these minor setbacks, its performance and affordability are worth mentioning."
15. Best All-Day Lasting: Kayla-Ism Black Eyeliner
Kayla-Ism is a super-classy drugstore eyeliner that outlines your eyes beautifully and changes your complete look with a single application. It comes with an ultra-fine tip and is quick to apply, quick-drying, and waterproof. Complement your outfit with the rich pigment of this eyeliner that lasts almost all day and enhances your existing makeup.
"I love the liner's sleek, longer brush, which is ideal for creating precise cat-eye looks. It's gentle on my skin and remarkably waterproof. Overall, it is a reliable choice for all-day wear."
16. Best Cruelty-Free: Palladio Eye Ink Liquid Eyeliner
Palladio eyeliner comes with a smooth tip and offers a jet-black texture to your eyes. It glides effortlessly on the eye to create a simple and sleek or thick and bold look. Additionally, this is a cruelty-free drugstore liquid eyeliner, as it is not tested on animals. Apply this anytime on any occasion in roughly a minute or carry it with you for instant application on the go.
17. Best Ultra-Fine: L A Colors Liquid Eyeliner
Let the brush slide on your beautiful eyes to give them an ultra-fine look for the day. The L.A Colors eyeliner in blue is something new and different from the black eyeliners. The waterproof and smudge-free eyeliner complements your outfit and is easy-to-use when you are in a rush. It dries quickly and remains intact no matter how long the day.
How To Choose The Right Drugstore Liquid Eyeliner?
Here are a few things to keep in mind when shopping for a drugstore liquid eyeliner.
- Decide upon the exact drugstore liquid eyeliner brand you want to invest in. Not all brands make the same variety of eyeliner, and not all brands are vegan-friendly or cruelty-free.
- Make sure you check the tip of the liner, whether it is pinpointed, bit tilted, or pen-shaped. The perfect liner would give a perfect shape.
- Check the longevity of the liner to know how many hours it could keep you work-ready. Opt for a liner made with a long-lasting formula.
- Also, the finish of the eyeliner must be as desired. Again, not all eyeliners give the same finish. So, check that before picking one.
- Look for eyeliners that are free of chemicals and added fragrances. Ideal ones would be ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-tested. Also, look for ones that provide ease of removal to further protect the delicate skin around the eyes.
, a licensed makeup artist and owner of Marin Eve Makeup, says, “The easiest eyeliner to work with is one with a felt tip. It is versatile and can be used for creating natural or glamorous looks or achieving a graphic eye look.” She adds, “Also, consider a waterproof liner, as it usually has good staying power. And when unsure which finish is best for you, consider matte as it offers a classic look.”
She adds, “Also, consider a waterproof formula, as it usually has good staying power. And when unsure which finish is best for you, consider matte as it offers a classic look.”
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is liquid or pencil eyeliner better?
Pencil eyeliners are an ideal choice for beginners as they are easy to work with, while long-lasting smudge-proof liquid eyeliners have a rich color and provide a smooth and intense application. The latter is also a better choice to achieve a dramatic winged eyeliner look.
2. Should I wear black or brown eyeliner?
Black eyeliners are ideal for creating a sharp wing and sleek look, while brown eyeliners are the best choice for creating a soft look and adding intensity to the eyes.
3. Can I put eyeliner on top and bottom?
Yes, you may apply the eyeliner on the top and bottom of your eyelashes depending on the look you want to create. But using liquid eyeliner on the bottom lashes may smudge and needs more care and perfection.
Why Trust MomJunction?
Poulami Nag holds an interest in beauty and skincare products. Keeping your convenience and quality parameters in mind, she has compiled a list of the best drugstore liquid eyeliners for you. With extensive research, she has provided a detailed description of each product, including its longevity, ease of application, and finish. You can choose from various affordable eyeliners after going through the helpful purchasing guide.
The Bottom Line
The best drugstore liquid eyeliners are must-haves in your makeup kit, as they help accentuate your eyes and give them the sparkle you have always wished for. To get the best look, pick one that glides smoothly and allows precision lining. It is equally important to choose one based on your skin tone and eye color. We recommend the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner for its tapered brush and cruelty-free formula, and the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, which is smudge-proof and long-lasting. Furthermore, you may also consider selecting an ophthalmologist- or dermatologist-tested eyeliner, such as the Maybelline Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner.
Infographic: How To Apply Liquid Eyeliner?
Although tricky to apply, liquid eyeliners can help you perfect the winged look. However, certain tips and tricks can help make your eyeliner application hassle-free. Follow the infographic below to learn how to apply liquid eyeliners correctly. Illustration: Momjunction Design Team
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our nurturing community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with fellow parents.
Read full bio of Marin McCarthy
Read full bio of Poulami Nag
Read full bio of Wedetso Chirhah
Read full bio of Deyasini Biswas
